Skip to content

Moments that matter

3 live

Picked from 10 matches by what is happening and what the model expected

Leagues
← ScoresTimes: UK time

Premier League· 2026/27 · Matchweek 8

Aston Villa v Manchester City

Aston VillaN. Jackson 6′, 60′
2–1FT · HT 1–0
Manchester CityE. Haaland 52′

· Villa Park, Birmingham

Data checked Details
  • Data last checked ; unchanged since
  • Kick-off UK time
  • Referee: P. Bankes
  • Where to watch
  • Kick-off
  • Villa Park, Birmingham
  • Referee: P. Bankes
  • Data last checked ; unchanged since

ModelWhat was forecast, what happened

Pre-match forecast, frozen at kick-off. It does not update during the match.

Result: ⁨Aston Villa⁩ win. The model gave it 21.1%. Ranked probability score for this match 0.458 (0 is perfect). One match says little: the model's record

Goals: expected and scored

Model, before kick-off
⁦1.11 – 1.87⁩
Chances created (match xG)
⁦0.61 – 1.56⁩
Goals
⁦2 – 1⁩

Likeliest scores before kick-off

  • ⁦1–1⁩ 11.7%
  • ⁦1–2⁩ 9.9%
  • ⁦0–2⁩ 8.9%
  • ⁦0–1⁩ 8.3%
  • ⁦0–0⁩ 6.2%

⁦2–1⁩ was not among them.

Every version, never edited

  1. v1Early pre-match ·
  2. v2Early pre-match ·
  3. v3Confirmed line-ups ·

dixon-coles-elo@0.6.0 · v3 computed 24 Oct, 12:03 UK time, 26 min before kick-off · Confirmed line-ups · fitted 23 Oct on 1,120 matches since Oct 2023 · Elo prior on · inputs complete

Why these numbers: leading factors and what changed between versions

Your pick

Locked at kick-off

Picks lock at kick-off.

Other predictions of this match

Founder’s analysis

None yet
The founder has not written an analysis of this match.

Community picks

Under 5
Fewer than 5 members have predicted this match, so there is no consensus to show yet.

Approved contributors

None yet
No contributor has published an analysis of this match.

Three separate products, never blended.

Key events available

  1. 12:30Kick-off
  2. 6′Goal · Aston VillaN. Jackson · (assist J. McGinn)
  3. 32′Yellow card · Manchester CityM. Guéhi
  4. 38′Yellow card · Manchester CityR. Cherki
  5. 52′Goal · Manchester CityE. Haaland · (assist I. Ndiaye)
  6. 54′Yellow card · Aston VillaJ. Manzambi
  7. 55′Yellow card · Aston VillaM. Cash
  8. 60′Goal · Aston VillaN. Jackson · (assist I. Mbaye)
  9. 74′Yellow card · Manchester CityE. Anderson
  10. 76′Yellow card · Manchester CityR. McAidoo
  11. 83′Yellow card · Aston VillaB. Madjo
  12. 90+5′Yellow card · Aston VillaE. Buendía
Substitutions (8)
  1. 46′Substitution · Manchester CityP. Foden on · R. Cherki off
  2. 46′Substitution · Manchester CityR. Lewis on · M. Guéhi off
  3. 59′Substitution · Aston VillaI. Mbaye on · Alysson off
  4. 66′Substitution · Aston VillaR. Barkley on · J. McGinn off
  5. 66′Substitution · Aston VillaE. Buendía on · J. Manzambi off
  6. 69′Substitution · Manchester CityR. McAidoo on · I. Ndiaye off
  7. 82′Substitution · Aston VillaL. Goretzka on · J. Gomes off
  8. 82′Substitution · Aston VillaB. Madjo on · N. Jackson off

Match summary

No written summary for this match

Statistics available

Match

  • 36%Possession64%
  • 0.61Expected goals (xG)1.56

Attack

  • 8Shots15
  • 2Shots on target7
  • 3Shots off target4
  • 3Blocked shots4
  • 4Corners7
  • 1Offsides2
  • 6Saves0

Passing

  • 314Passes543
  • 254Accurate passes488
  • 81%Pass accuracy90%

Discipline

  • 21Fouls17
  • 4Yellow cards4
  • 0Red cards0

Player statistics available

Scroll sideways to see every column.

Aston Villa
PlayerMinRatingGoalsAssistsShotsKey passesTackles
B. Kamara906.900006
I. Maatsen906.600104
M. Cash906.600018
P. Torres906.700000
V. Lindelöf906.900001
Z. Suzuki909.000000
J. Gomes826.600011
N. Jackson829.220301
J. Manzambi666.900103
J. McGinn667.501041
Alysson596.700203
I. Mbaye316.701010
E. Buendía246.300003
R. Barkley246.700000
B. Madjo86.600000
L. Goretzka86.300000
Manchester City
PlayerMinRatingGoalsAssistsShotsKey passesTackles
A. Khusanov907.300108
E. Anderson907.300031
E. Fernández907.200120
E. Haaland907.910200
G. Donnarumma904.900000
J. Doku907.300220
J. Gvardiol906.300323
R. Dias906.500000
I. Ndiaye697.301210
M. Guéhi455.900000
P. Foden456.700110
R. Cherki456.200120
R. Lewis456.200001
R. McAidoo216.900010

– no figure supplied for this player; a 0 is a supplied zero.

Expected goals by player available

Licensed match data, from a source of its own: kept apart from the player statistics above and never combined with them.

Aston Villa
PlayerxGxAxGOT
N. Jackson0.360.020.32
Alysson0.100.01–
I. Maatsen0.070.02–
J. Manzambi0.070.00–
B. Kamara–0.00–
B. Madjo–0.00–
E. Buendía–0.00–
I. Mbaye–0.04–
J. Gomes–0.00–
J. McGinn–0.07–
L. Goretzka–0.00–
M. Cash–0.00–
P. Torres–0.00–
R. Barkley–0.00–
V. Lindelöf–0.00–
Z. Suzuki–0.00–
Manchester City
PlayerxGxAxGOT
J. Gvardiol0.680.040.56
E. Haaland0.400.001.56
R. Cherki0.390.040.42
J. Doku0.160.42–
I. Ndiaye0.060.410.16
E. Fernández0.040.40–
P. Foden0.040.19–
A. Khusanov0.020.050.04
E. Anderson–0.24–
G. Donnarumma–0.00–
M. Guéhi–0.00–
R. Lewis–0.01–
R. Dias–0.02–
R. McAidoo–0.06–

– no figure supplied for this player; a 0 is a supplied zero.

Line-ups available

Manchester City4-2-3-1

  1. 1Donnarumma4.9
  1. 45Khusanov7.3
  2. 6GuéhiBooked 32′ · Off 46′5.9
  3. 3Dias (c)6.5
  4. 24Gvardiol6.3
  1. 5AndersonBooked 74′7.3
  2. 17Fernández7.2
  1. 7NdiayeOff 69′7.3
  2. 10CherkiBooked 38′ · Off 46′6.2
  3. 11Doku7.3
  1. 9HaalandGoal 52′7.9
  1. 11JacksonGoal 6′ · Goal 60′ · Off 82′9.2
  1. 44ManzambiBooked 54′ · Off 66′6.9
  2. 7McGinn (c)Off 66′7.5
  3. 47AlyssonOff 59′6.7
  1. 35GomesOff 82′6.6
  2. 8Kamara6.9
  1. 22Maatsen6.6
  2. 14Torres6.7
  3. 3Lindelöf6.9
  4. 2CashBooked 55′6.6
  1. 1Suzuki9.0

Aston Villa4-2-3-1

Each player stands where the line-up places him: in his line from the goalkeeper, and on his side of the pitch as his team attacks.

Aston Villa · Bench

Coach: Unai Emery

Manchester City · Bench

Coach: Enzo Maresca

Key players

Aston Villaavailable

  1. V. Lindelöf · Defender630 min in 7 matches · 0 goals · 0 assistsNot on the absence list
  2. B. Kamara · Midfielder624 min in 7 matches · 0 goals · 1 assistNot on the absence list
  3. J. McGinn · Midfielder571 min in 7 matches · 1 goal · 2 assistsNot on the absence list

From player figures for all 7 matches played.

Manchester Cityavailable

  1. M. Guéhi · Defender630 min in 7 matches · 1 goal · 1 assistNot on the absence list
  2. G. Donnarumma · Goalkeeper630 min in 7 matches · 0 goals · 0 assistsNot on the absence list
  3. R. Dias · Defender630 min in 7 matches · 0 goals · 0 assistsNot on the absence list

From player figures for all 7 matches played.

Availability as last checked, .

Key players are each side's 3 with the most minutes in Premier League 2026/27 before this match, counted from each match's player figures; a tie on minutes goes to more goals plus assists, then the name. Goals and assists are summed from the same figures. This is a count, not a judgement of quality, and no rating is used.

Statistical model

How the forecast was reachedavailable

The forecast and every version are in the summary; this section only says why.

Computed by Stadiomind’s statistical model from match data. Not a person’s opinion.

The model gives Manchester City the most probability, 29.2 points ahead of the next outcome. Every outcome remains possible; these are probabilities, not a prediction of the result.

Leading factors

  • Team strength · favours Manchester City · net strength (attack minus defence) from recent results and the Elo prior
  • Attack against defence · favours Manchester City · how the sides' attacks match up against the opposing defences
  • Home advantage · favours Aston Villa · league-wide home advantage learned from the training window

What changed between versions

  1. v1 · Early pre-match: first available version.
  2. v2 · No change in probabilities (early pre-match).
    2 inputs changed together — history up to (16 Oct 2026 → 17 Oct 2026), history from (12 Oct 2023 → 13 Oct 2023) — so the move cannot be put down to any one of them.
  3. v3 · Aston Villa -1.3, draw -0.3, Manchester City +1.6 points (confirmed line-ups).
    3 inputs changed together — history up to (17 Oct 2026 → 23 Oct 2026), matches in the fit (1,110 → 1,120), history from (13 Oct 2023 → 19 Oct 2023) — so the move cannot be put down to any one of them. The model does not read line-ups yet, so this version is one computed when the line-up was confirmed, not one computed from it.

Post-match evaluation

Result 2–1: Aston Villa. Version 3 (Confirmed line-ups) gave that outcome 21.1%, not its most probable outcome. Log loss 1.556, Brier 0.977 (lower is better; knowing nothing scores 1.099 and 0.667).

Both numbers measure how much probability the model put on what really happened. Here both are worse than knowing nothing.

Evaluated

How accurate has the model been?

Power Index

Aston Villa45.1
Manchester City90.5
Aston Villa — 45.195% measured

Driven mostly by expected or confirmed line-up quality, underlying team strength and recent opponent-adjusted performance.

  • Underlying team strength35% of the index
    Ahead of 63% of this competition
  • Recent opponent-adjusted performance20% of the index
    Ahead of 28% of this competition
  • Expected or confirmed line-up quality20% of the index
    Ahead of 26% of this competition
  • Venue effect10% of the index
    Ahead of 78% of this competition
  • Rest, travel and schedule5% of the index
    Bottom 10% of this competition — 2 days since the previous match, 4 in the last 14; travel not modelled
  • Competition context5% of the index
    Not available — not modelled: needs the stakes of this stage and the team’s other commitments
  • Managerial and team stability5% of the index
    Ahead of 41% of this competition

95% of the index was measurable. Not included: competition context.

Manchester City — 90.595% measured

Driven mostly by underlying team strength, expected or confirmed line-up quality and recent opponent-adjusted performance.

  • Underlying team strength35% of the index
    Top 10% of this competition
  • Recent opponent-adjusted performance20% of the index
    Top 10% of this competition
  • Expected or confirmed line-up quality20% of the index
    Top 10% of this competition
  • Venue effect10% of the index
    Top 10% of this competition
  • Rest, travel and schedule5% of the index
    Bottom 10% of this competition — 3 days since the previous match, 4 in the last 14; travel not modelled
  • Competition context5% of the index
    Not available — not modelled: needs the stakes of this stage and the team’s other commitments
  • Managerial and team stability5% of the index
    Ahead of 51% of this competition

95% of the index was measurable. Not included: competition context.

Formula [email protected], computed 24 Oct, 12:03 UK time. 0–100 is this team’s standing in its competition, not a probability.

Where to watch

Choose your territory to see where this match is shown. It is never guessed from your address.

Match discussion

Nobody has opened a discussion on this match.

Nobody has opened a discussion on this match.